YAYRA
没有和解,暴力依旧。历史悲剧不会随着时间消散而是一种反复回返的集体恐惧和政治现实。
Marlboro.
+或许应该从此处开始学习电影的陌生
持人的摄影机
8.0/10。①一个德国中产家庭近半个世纪(大概1910-1960)的变迁,展现了这段德国历史的一个切面。②一种「几乎无主观情绪、仿佛在读一篇抽离了作者主观情感的极其客观的论文」(即toneless)的影调的营造:冷静无感情的旁白;零度表演/布莱希特式表演;平淡的叙事节奏;简约干净的布光;结构复杂(甚至分不清时间先后)的非线性叙事(大大增强了观众对故事的共情难度,从而将观众间离出来看故事);等。③很明显,②中所说的影调的目的是让观众能理性地、不带个人情感地去客观地理解分析故事,但本片过于复杂晦涩的叙事结构却导致观众根本难以看懂故事(甚至故事不一定有唯一解),所以影调的作用大打折扣。
The subtitle of Jean-Marie Straub and Danièle Huillet’s first feature, from 1965, “Only Violence Helps Where Violence Reigns,” suggests the fierce political program evoked by their rigorous aesthetic. The pretext of the film, set in Cologne, is Heinrich Böll’s novel “Billiards at Half Past Nine,” which they strip down to a handful of stark events and film with a confrontational angularity akin to Bartók’s music that adorns the soundtrack. The subtlest of cues accompany the story’s complex flashbacks. The middle-aged Robert Fähmel tells a young hotel bellhop of persecutions under the Third Reich his elderly father, Heinrich, an architect famed for a local abbey, recalls the militarism of the First World War, when his wife, Johanna, incurred trouble for insulting the Kaiser. A third-generation Fähmel is considering architecture, just as the exiled brother of Robert’s late wife, returns, only to be met by their former torturer, now a West German official taking part in a celebratory parade of war veterans. Straub and Huillet make the layers of history live in the present tense, which they judge severely. The tamped-down acting and the spare, tense visual rhetoric suggest a state of moral crisis as well as the response—as much in style as in substance—that it demands.